Design and testing of a dry sanitation unit for treatment and disposal of human faeces
Loading...
Date
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Vaal University of Technology
Abstract
South Africa has challenges on its own in providing adequate sanitation. The provision of safe and dignified sanitation in South Africa is currently hindered by a lack of resources such as water, infrastructure networks, and energy. The existing sewerage systems rely on costly networks of pipes and significant amounts of drinkable water, which is unsustainable as the population and urbanization continue to grow rapidly. Additionally, climate change has introduced new challenges, such as droughts in some areas, highlighting the importance of water conservation. In a water-scarce country like South Africa, using water for flushing toilets is seen as wasteful.
In response to the sanitation crisis in South Africa, The Water Research Commission (WRC) of South Africa established an initiative called “The Re-Engineered Toilet”, which encouraged developing new sanitation technologies in South Africa. The challenge called for designs which take into aesthetics, user preferences and habits, operates completely off the grid, consumes little energy or utilises off the grid energy supply, uses little or no water, has potential for resource recovery, and novel sanitation treatment processes such as electro-catalytic, pyrolysis, incineration, accelerated drying, and carbonisation.
This study was established under the re-invented toilet challenge and aimed to develop a concept for a dry sanitation unit that uses drying and thermochemical treatment to dispose of human faeces. The research investigated the optimal parameters required for the treatment processes and used these to design and test a prototype of the sanitation unit.
For the design of a dry sanitation system that continuously dries faeces, it is important to measure the throughput in terms of frequency and amount of defaecation as well as moisture content of the faeces. A total of 20 people were surveyed over a period of 10 weeks for frequency of defaecation per day, mass of each defaecation occurrence and moisture content of the faeces.
Drying experiments were performed in a tunnel column with convective drying as the main mechanism for drying. Samples were dried for a period of 300 minutes (5 hours) for each sample. Drying was conducted at moderate near-ambient conditions, with temperatures of 20, 25, 30, 35 and 40 ℃, and air flows of 0.1, 0.2 and 0.5 m/s, at relative humidity of 5, 10, 20 and 40%, and initial moisture content of 82.2, 78.1, 71.7, 71.1 and 64.2%.The conditions we selected on the basis that the temperature and air velocity can be obtained using solar air heater and wind-driven extractor fan, without the need for electricity or heating fuel. Drying characteristics were calculated by fitting drying models to the experimental data and determining the drying parameters.
Samples of human faeces that were collected during the drying experiments were used for pyrolysis and combustion experiments. All samples were slow dried at 35 °C for 6 hours to maintain the same basis for the equilibrium moisture content of the faeces. A total of 12 samples were used in these experiments, with a mass of 20 g used in each of the combustion experiments and 10 g used in each of the pyrolysis experiments. Each of the samples were sent for proximate and ultimate analysis.
A conceptual design of the proposed dry sanitation system was developed and constructed. A prototype of the drying system was built and then tested for functionality using some guidelines from the ISO 30500 standard for non-sewered sanitation systems. The drying system consisting of a drying bed, a solar air heater and a wind driven turbine ventilator was tested. The system was designed for household application. Simulated faeces was used to test the range of conditions the samples would be exposed to and the resultant moisture content. Operational challenges were also noted and recommendations for adjustment were made.
Another aspect of the research was quantifying excreta generated in school sanitation facilities. The aim was to inform designers of school sanitation facilities on the capacities that they need to design for. A model was developed to predict sanitation system usage based on literature values for frequency and timing of defaecation and urination. The model was calibrated with usage data obtained from surveys at three schools.
For the surveyed group of people, the frequency of defecation varied from one to three times a day with a sample mean of 1.15. The mass of faeces collected per defaecation varied from 42.8 to 424.9 g with a sample mean of 172.5 g. The moisture content of the surveyed faeces samples varied from 58.4 to 92.1% with sample mean of 72.3%.
The experimental data curves for faeces for varying temperatures were fitted to the Newton, the Henderson and Pabis, the Page, and the Midilli-Kucuk models, while other experimental conditions were kept constant. Page model was the best fitting model, with R2 values ranging from 0.9950 to 09977. Effective moisture diffusivity and convective mass transfer coefficient were found to vary from 8.81 x 10-8 m2/s and 1.31x 10-5 m/s at 20 ℃ to 9.57 x 10-7 m2/s and 3.49 x 10-4 m/s at 40 ℃, respectively. The activation energy was found to be 42.38 kJ/mol.
Combustion required an accelerant to initiate the process, but after sufficient time, was self-sustaining. The 20 g sample was reduced to ash within a 50-minute period, the combustion temperature reaches a peak of 370°C degrees after 35 minutes. Smoke particles detected were similar to smoke particles detected in the combustion of wood. For pyrolysis, the factors investigated were the char yield and the gas analysis. The biochar produced from the 10g samples were between 33.1 and 35.6% of its initial mass. The gas analysis showed that in the early in the temperature ramping up phase from 150 to 300°C, CO and CO2 C2H6 as the main constituents. Above 400°C degrees, the pyrolysis gas comprises mainly of H2 and CO. The gases quickly diminished at temperature of 500°C indicating that pyrolysis is complete which shows that this may be the optimum temperature for treatment with pyrolysis.
• During prototype testing, the following scenarios were tested:
• Normal loading rates under normal ambient conditions (average temperature of 22°C and humidity of 47%)
• Normal loading rates under high humidity (average temperate of 24.9°C and average humidity of 76%)
• Higher loading rates
• Normal loading rates under dry and hot ambient conditions (average temperate of 30.1°C and average humidity of 42%)
Dry solids were obtained during favourable conditions, such as moderate to hot temperatures and low humidity. However, on very humid days without much sunshine, the solids were not dried effectively, with samples off-loaded with moisture contents of about 20%. This poor performance at high humidity presents a real challenge for rainy days, which could go continuously for more than a week at once. For this reason, it was recommended that the dry solids storage pit be continuously supplied with solar-heated air to continue drying after the sample has been discharged from the tunnel.
Overall, the drying tunnel has been shown to sufficiently dry faeces in different context and using small adjustments such as increasing air temperatures in humid conditions and at high loading rates can assist in drying the faeces further. Designing a small holding chamber that is also fed with drying air can dry the stored faeces further.
Description
Ph. D. (Chemical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering and Technology), Vaal University of Technology.